NEW YORK CITY GUIDE
The Best Luxury Consignment Stores in New York City
The complete directory of places to buy, sell, and consign luxury handbags and designer goods in NYC — with honest notes on pricing, fees, and what each place is actually good for.
Last updated: March 2026
Quick fee comparison: selling an $8,000 bag
| Option | Typical Fee | You Keep |
|---|---|---|
| National consignment site | 30–40% | $4,800 – $5,600 |
| Local consignment shop | 35–50% | $4,000 – $5,200 |
| Direct buyback store | 35–45% | $4,400 – $5,200 |
| Purr (peer-to-peer) | 10% | $7,200 |
Upper East Side
Encore Resale
1132 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028
An Upper East Side institution for decades. Known for exceptional vintage designer pieces and uptown elegance. The clientele here is old-money UES — consignment rates are competitive and the staff really knows their vintage.
Michael's Consignment
1125 Madison Ave, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10028
A Madison Ave legend since 1954. Michael's is where Upper East Side women have consigned their designer wardrobes for generations. The upstairs location keeps it discreet. Incredible for couture, runway, and classic luxury. Consignment splits are fair, and the staff has seen everything.
michaelsconsignment.comDesigner Revival
1065 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028
A sleek boutique on Madison Ave focused on authenticated luxury handbags. Strong Hermès and Chanel inventory. They buy outright and do consignment, with competitive pricing on both sides. Clean, well-organized shop that feels more like a boutique than a resale store.
designerrevival.comLa Boutique Resale
1045 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10075
A polished Madison Ave resale shop with a carefully curated selection. Known for fair pricing and a personal touch. The owner is hands-on and selective about what she takes, which means your consigned pieces get real attention and sell faster.
Decadestwo
Upper East Side, Manhattan
Highly curated vintage designer shop. The sister concept to the LA Decades store. More editorial and collector-focused — great for rare and archival luxury pieces that appreciate over time.
A Second Chance Resale
Upper East Side, New York, NY
A family-owned resale shop that's been serving the UES for over 20 years. Also has a SoHo location. They know their clientele and price accordingly. The personal, multi-generational approach means real relationships and fair deals on both sides.
Matiell
Upper East Side, New York, NY
A UES spot that leans heavily into handbags and accessories alongside designer clothing. The brand mix is interesting — you'll find top-tier luxury next to accessible designer names, which means a broader buyer pool for consignors. The focus on bags makes it worth knowing about if you're shopping for or selling accessories specifically.
Margoth Consignment Shop
Upper East Side, New York, NY
A quiet Upper East Side consignment shop that's been in business since 2001. Margoth keeps a refined selection and attracts a loyal uptown clientele. Not flashy, just consistently well-curated with fair consignment terms.
margothconsignment.shopSoHo & NoHo
Opulent Habits
New York, NY
NYC-based online luxury consignment with periodic in-person shopping events around the city. Strong authentication process and a curated selection of bags. Good option if you prefer browsing online but want a local seller.
opulenthabits.comSoHo Luxury Exchange
SoHo, New York, NY
A SoHo resale shop that leads with authentication and sustainability. Every bag is verified before it hits the floor, which builds trust on both sides. The sustainable fashion angle resonates with the downtown crowd, and the handbag-forward inventory means serious selection if that's what you're after.
shopatsoho.comWhat Goes Around Comes Around
351 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013
A SoHo landmark since 1993. One of the most respected vintage luxury dealers in the world. Their Chanel and Hermès selection is museum-quality. They buy outright for select pieces — bring your best. Prices are premium but authentication is impeccable.
whatgoesaroundnyc.comIna
15 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012
A downtown favorite since the '90s. Ina is where stylists and editors consign and shop. The selection skews fashion-forward — expect current-season designer alongside timeless luxury. Multiple locations around downtown Manhattan. Consignment splits are competitive and pieces move fast with their tastemaker clientele.
inanyc.comThe Vintage Twin
83 Grand St, New York, NY 10013
A SoHo vintage shop with a fashion-forward point of view. Strong on vintage luxury accessories and statement pieces. They buy outright for desirable vintage — especially anything Chanel, Dior, or Fendi from the '90s and 2000s. Popular with stylists pulling for shoots.
thevintagetwin.comBeacon's Closet — SoHo area
10 W 13th St, New York, NY 10011
More contemporary and vintage than ultra-luxury, but occasional gems surface. They buy outright — cash or trade credit (30% cash, 50% trade). Good for offloading mid-range designer quickly. Don't bring your Birkin, but your Maje and Sandro will move.
beaconscloset.comBuffalo Exchange — SoHo
332 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003
Walk-in, cash or trade on the spot. 30% cash or 50% trade credit. Best for contemporary brands — Reformation, AllSaints, COS. Not the place for high-end luxury, but fast and easy for clearing out your closet.
buffaloexchange.comUpper West Side
Consignment on 72nd
Upper West Side, New York, NY
A newer addition to the UWS consignment scene, opened in 2024. Fresh inventory and a clean, modern shop feel. They're still building their reputation but the early selection is promising and the neighborhood needed a dedicated luxury consignment option.
Brooklyn
Beacon's Closet — Bushwick
23 Bogart St, Brooklyn, NY 11206
The Bushwick location draws a younger, creative crowd. Same deal as the other locations: walk in, sell on the spot. More streetwear and contemporary than ultra-luxury, but the sheer volume means designer gems surface regularly.
beaconscloset.comBeacon's Closet — Williamsburg
74 Guernsey St, Brooklyn, NY 11222
The original Beacon's Closet location. Williamsburg's go-to for secondhand. Mostly contemporary and vintage, but luxury pieces do surface. If you're selling, it's fast — they buy on the spot. 30% cash or 50% trade.
beaconscloset.comL Train Vintage
Multiple Brooklyn locations
More of a treasure hunt than a consignment shop. You won't find rows of Chanel here, but savvy shoppers occasionally score designer pieces at thrift prices. Better for buying than selling luxury.
Housing Works
Various — check website for nearest
A nonprofit thrift chain. Luxury finds are rare but real — wealthy Upper East Siders donate to Housing Works regularly. The Bookstore Cafe in SoHo and the Chelsea location tend to get the best designer donations. All proceeds support housing and healthcare.
housingworks.orgOnline (NYC-Based)
ThredUp
Online — order a clean-out kit
Massive online consignment platform. They send you a bag, you fill it, they handle everything. Payouts are lower than luxury-specific platforms (expect 15-40% of resale price), but it's extremely convenient for bulk cleanouts.
thredup.comTips for selling in NYC
The Upper East Side is your best bet for top dollar. Madison Ave between 60th and 80th has the highest concentration of luxury consignment stores in the country. Walk the strip and get multiple quotes in a single afternoon — Encore, Michael's, Designer Revival, and La Boutique Resale are all within blocks of each other.
Know what you have before you walk in. The biggest advantage you can have when consigning or selling is knowing the current market value of your bag. Stores are more likely to offer a fair price when they know you've done your research. Scan your bag with Purr before you visit any store — you'll know instantly if their offer is reasonable.
Compare offers. There's no rule that says you have to accept the first offer. Get quotes from 2-3 places. The difference between a direct buyback price and a patient consignment sale can be 20-30% — thousands of dollars on a high-value bag.
Timing matters. The best time to sell in NYC is September through November (holiday buying season and fall fashion). The Met Gala and NYFW periods also drive interest in luxury resale. January-February is the slowest — post-holiday returns flood the market.
Condition is everything. A bag in excellent condition with box, dust bag, receipt, and authentication card will sell for 10-20% more than the same bag without accessories. Keep your packaging.
Consider peer-to-peer. If you're willing to handle the listing yourself, selling directly to another person — whether through Purr or even locally — lets you keep significantly more. The convenience of consignment costs real money.
Own a store? Get featured.
We're building the most complete luxury consignment directory in LA. Add your store for free — and get early access to Purr for Business.
Purr scans your bags and shows you real market data — so you never walk into a consignment store uninformed. Join the waitlist.